Skip to main content

Conservation and Land Ethics: A Review of Leopold's A Sand County Almanac

One of the central themes of A Sand County Almanac is Leopold's observation of nature and his reflection on the ways of the natural world. In the beginning, Leopold follows the tracks of a skunk that has just come out of hibernation during the January thaw. In his essays on March and May, he tells of the returning geese and the upland plover bringing news of spring's arrival. Leopold also speaks fondly of seeing the annual bloom of a certain flower in July (cutleaf silphium). His words on this, however, are heavy with sorrow for the loss of this plant species, which is nearly extinct, save for this spot alongside the Wisconsin highway.

Leopold writes in regard to this remnant of western natural history: "The Highway Department says that 100,000 cars pass yearly over this route during the three summer months when the silphium is in bloom. In them must ride at least 100,000 people who have 'taken' what is called history, and perhaps 25,000 who have 'taken' what is called botany. Yet I doubt whether a dozen have seen the Silphium, and of these hardly one will notice its demise" (pg 49). In this passage, the author expresses sorrow over the demise of once great fields of Silphium but possibly more so over the fact that to the majority of the human population, this species fade into history will go unnoticed. This concern for the natural world is indicative of Leopold's ecocentric views. This philosophy is the true theme of Leopold's writing and is evident throughout A Sand County Almanac.
Leopold portrays his affection for living things and his sorrow over the loss of the natural world in many ways in A Sand County Almanac but most notably in his telling of the sawing of an oak. The tree had been struck by lightning, which brought it down, and while this saddened Leopold, he did not express anger towards the lightning, rather, he saw the event as a natural process that, while sad, could be used towards a good purpose. " . . .we knew that the lightning had bequeathed to us three cords of prospective fuel wood" (pg 9).
Leopold eloquently tells the story of this tree's life and the many years that it stood strong while the world around it changed. As he cuts through the tree, he link's each growth ring to a year in human history. He evokes vivid images with his words as he takes the reader back through his ownership of the land and his predecessor's, back through the decades of the great depression, back through the decades of expanding cities in the 1890's, and back to the establishment of Wisconsin farmlands. Leopold clearly takes note of the historical significance of nature, and he seems to understand and bemoan the fact that the natural world is often ignored when people look at history.
Many people have a tendency to believe that the only important history involves the actions of other humans. Leopold, however, expresses the view that all nature has historical relevance, whether it's an old tree standing strong through hundreds of years of change and turmoil, a prairie flower harkening back to the days of the old west, or a bird flying the same route and eating of the same plants as its ancestors. This reflects his view that nature has inherent value and does not merely exist for the benefit of mankind .
This leads into the aspect of A Sand County Almanac that has most influenced conservation-the land ethic. Leopold explains that the community concept of ethics is a process of cooperation and that "the land ethic simply enlarges the boundaries of the community to include, soils, waters, plants, and animals, or collectively: the land" (pg 239). The land ethic, however, does not seek to end all human uses of the land.
Leopold states that a land ethic cannot prevent alteration, management, and use of these resources but rather it does affirm their right to exist. In other words, the ethical theory that Leopold puts forth is the notion that, while we may use the land and its resources, that is not its only value, and a land's value should not be measured solely on the basis of economic factors.
Many people believe that if an area of land is not fertile that it is worthless; they believe that if an animal does not feed people or in some other respect aid the human race it is of no value; they believe that the land and all of the animals on it are here for our benefit. A Sand County Almanac disputes these beliefs. Sand County itself is thought of as a wasteland by many, but Leopold writes about the intrinsic value of the land instead of focusing merely on the resources to be exploited by man. Furthermore, the land ethic seeks to place humans on the same level as other animals and to give the rest of the natural community the same right to exist that humans have "In short,
While reading A Sand County Almanac, the reader is taken from observations of everyday natural occurrences to strong statements of the need for ethical, political, and philosophical consideration of natural issues. It is this combination of simplicity and profound contemplation that make this book a classic.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sex Offender Treatment and Recidivism

"Sexual assault is a multi-factored behavioral phenomenon that has been identified as a leading social and criminal justice problem" ( drc.state.oh.us ) Sexual assault has affected the lives of millions of people and is a serious criminal justice and a social problem. According to a study from the department of justice surveying trends of sex crimes between 1983 and 1995, persons age 12 or older reported experiencing an estimated 260,300 attempted or completed rapes and nearly 95,000 threatened or completed sexual assaults other than rape in 1995 (usdoj). In 2004, there were 209,880 victims of rape, attempted rape or sexual assaults ( rain.org ). According to the 1997 Sex Offense and Offenders Study from the Department of Justice and 1999 National Crime Victimization Study (as cited on  www.rainn.org ), the following statistics illustrate the problems present for society in regard to sex crimes. Every two and a half minutes, somewhere in America, someone is sexually assault...

College Paper: Critical Analysis of Antigone

Below is a copy of an English Comp II paper on Antigone. For use as an example only. Critical Analysis of Antigone Themes of Life, Death, Sin, and Virtue Analysis of Sophocles' play Antigone and its major themes Antigone is a play similar to Oedipus Rex in its dark tone, mythical themes, and tragic story. However, Sophocles' writing seems clearer in this play, and Antigone is much more character-driven with complex, well developed characters. Through Sophocles' brilliant characterization of people at war with themselves, Inner conflict emerges as the central theme of the play. The play is all about conflict including the obvious themes like man's rules versus divine law, and pride versus honor; as well as the deeper subtext of each character's internal conflicts.   Kreon for example, is caught between his duty to the gods and his pride. His character has changed dramatically from the time of Oedipus to the events of Antigone. He is still aware of...

A Brief Look at the Eventful Life of Samuel Tilden

Samuel Jones Tilden was born in New Lebanon, New York in 1814. He was educated at Yale University and the University of the city of New York. He was admitted to the bar in 1841. [1]  Tilden became an outstanding corporation lawyer, who mastered the complexities of reorganizing and refinancing railroads. He amassed a fortune in fees, which he augmented by shrewd  investments  in railroads, iron mines, and real estate. [2] Tilden had shown leadership ability early in his political career. An ardent Jacksonian in the 1830's, Tilden became a leader in the 1840's of the Barnburners. [3]  "The Barnburners were a radical element of the Democratic party in New York State from 1842 to 1848. The name derives from the fabled Dutchman who burned his barn to rid it of rats; by implication, the Barnburners would destroy corporations and public works to do away with the abuses they foster". [4]  This alliance illustrated Tilden's commitment to the abolition of corruption. ...